Artificial intelligence is rewriting the rules of discovery. Search results are no longer a simple list of blue links. With tools like Google’s AI Mode delivering instant summaries, audiences often get what they need without clicking through to the original source. For publishers, this shift is already visible in their analytics. Mail Online reported click-through rates dropping by more than 50% when AI overviews appeared, even when the site ranked first in traditional search results.
For digital media executives, the implications are serious. Fewer visits mean fewer opportunities to monetize, weaker brand authority and a growing disconnect between audiences and the trusted outlets that produce the content. Readers develop loyalty to the aggregator, not the publisher. The challenge now is to reclaim direct relationships and remind audiences why visiting a publisher’s own site matters.
Strengthening the core
The first priority is to reinforce the value of a publisher’s own destination. Strong editorial identity and a clear brand voice give readers a reason to come back. Investigative reporting, live coverage and deeply reported opinion pieces resist machine-generated simplification and highlight a publisher’s expertise. Investing in these formats makes the brand indispensable and difficult for AI to replicate.
Loyalty programs can also deepen ties. Offering exclusive access, community recognition or tangible perks encourages habitual engagement without relying on restrictive paywalls. The goal is voluntary, not coerced, return visits. Readers should want to come back because the experience is worth it., rather than being pressured through paywalls, aggressive pop-ups, or other forms of friction that limit genuine choice.
Expanding discovery and engagement
Relying on search alone is no longer viable. Audience acquisition needs to extend across a wider ecosystem: partnerships with other respected outlets, distributed content on reliable platforms, curated newsletter growth and smart syndication. Each step reduces dependence on any single traffic source and introduces the brand to new readers. Some publishers have shown how effective this can be, with audience acquisition programs generating hundreds of millions of additional monthly page views across participating outlets, helping to fill gaps left by declining search traffic.
Discovery must also go beyond distribution. Publishers can build intentional paths into their ecosystems by embracing products like curated apps, podcasts, and social channels that are designed to funnel audiences back to their owned platforms. The goal is to make discovery a two-way street: audiences find the publisher, but the publisher also actively guides them toward deeper engagement.
Once visitors arrive, their time must count. Interactive storytelling, immersive explainers and vertical video feeds keep users exploring. Research shows vertical video can generate more than triple the time spent compared with high-impact display ads. Formats that encourage longer sessions strengthen the relationship and increase the value of every visit.
Using AI as an ally
Avoiding AI altogether is not the answer. Publishers can harness machine learning to improve personalization and relevance. AI-powered recommendation engines surface content tailored to individual preferences, reinforcing the brand’s value through context and depth. The key is to integrate AI as a tool for engagement while maintaining control of the narrative.
AI can also automate low-value newsroom tasks such as headline testing, tagging, or formatting, freeing journalists to focus on reporting that machines cannot replicate. At the same time, it strengthens the use of first-party data, helping publishers uncover patterns that drive more relevant content and advertising while respecting privacy. Used in this way, AI becomes less a threat and more a tool to deepen engagement, improve efficiency, and support the distinctive editorial voice that sets publishers apart.
Search and AI: navigating the road ahead
The next five years will determine which digital media companies maintain authority and revenue. Those that cultivate direct relationships, amplify unique editorial strengths and create richer on-site experiences will weather the volatility of platform-driven traffic. Those that don’t risk fading behind a layer of algorithms.
What is unfolding is not just a shift in referral traffic but a structural reordering of how information is discovered, trusted, and monetized. Search is no longer the dependable gateway it once was, and AI is accelerating the pace of change. Publishers that thrive will be those who see discovery as an ecosystem rather than a single channel, who treat loyalty as a relationship rather than a transaction, and who use technology to enhance — not replace — their editorial identity.
The future of publishing will not be decided by algorithms alone. It will be shaped by the ability of publishers to assert their value, claim their place in the open internet, and remind audiences that real journalism and original voices are worth seeking out.